Agencies/Agra


Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper and his wife Laureen pose in front of the historic Taj Mahal yesterday. Harper is on a six-day state visit to India
A high-profile tax dispute between the Indian government and British telecoms operator Vodafone Group has made it unlikely that India will sign a foreign investment protection treaty with Canada during a visit by Prime Minister Stephen Harper, Canada’s top diplomat in India said.
Canadian High Commissioner Stewart Beck also signalled an important disagreement with India in negotiations aimed at opening up Canadian exports of uranium to India.
There had been media speculation in both countries that Harper’s November 4-9 visit to India might yield a final agreement on foreign investment protection or on nuclear supplies or both, but this will now likely not happen this week.
“I imagine we’ll have agreements perhaps in the next year,” Beck told reporters travelling with Harper.
The Indian government is putting on hold all its negotiations with other countries on foreign investment protection agreements after Vodafone threatened the Indian government with arbitration proceedings under one that already exists between the Netherlands and India.
“They are taking a look at all their agreements before they finalise any one in particular,” Beck said.
“I would say this is going to take more time (than this week),” he said of the Canadian-Indian investment protection negotiations, which have been under way for eight years.
The $2.2bn Vodafone dispute concerns an Indian attempt to change tax laws in a way which would impact Vodafone retroactively.
On the question of atomic energy, India plans a major expansion of nuclear power, and it signed a nuclear co-operation agreement with Canada in 2010. But the two countries still need to agree on safeguards before Canada will allow its uranium to be exported to India.
“You don’t want your material to be diverted (to non-civilian purposes),” Beck said.
The disagreement centres on how to track what happens to the uranium.
“The Indians are saying that they report to the IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency), and because of that, that should be adequate for us,” he said.
But Canada wants to be able to track it directly.
“Our view is that we are concerned about where Canadian nuclear material goes,” he said.
Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard was talking uranium exports up during a visit to India last month, but her country also is seeking safeguards on where it will go.
Meanwhile, Canada’s Minister of State for Democratic Reforms Tim Uppal yesterday met Minister for Overseas Indian Affairs Vayalar Ravi in New Delhi.
“We have discussed issues relating to bilateral trade and ways to give it a boost,” Ravi told reporters after his meeting with Uppal, a Sikh and two-time MP from Edmonton-Sherwood Park.
Uppal is part of Harper’s team visiting India.
“There were also issues relating to the Persons of Indian Origin (PIO) card. A lot of PIOs have issues on the card and we discussed ways of sorting them out,” Ravi said.
Harper and his wife Laureen visited the Taj Mahal yesterday. He described the 17th century Mughal monument as a “gift of beauty for all humanity.”
“The visit lasted for one hour from 10.30am,” Archaeological Survey of India official in charge of the Taj Mahal, Munazzar Ali, said.
“This has been a real treat for Laureen and me. It is wonderful to see how such a monument for love for a queen has become a gift of beauty for all humanity,” Harper wrote in the Visitors’ Book.