President Donald Trump’s fight to keep his personal financial records private reaches a new stage today when US Supreme Court justices meet to consider up to three hotly-contested cases pitting Trump against congressional Democrats and a New York prosecutor.
The Republican president is trying to block subpoenas for bank records, tax returns or other materials demanded by various Democratic-led House of Representatives committees investigating corruption or foreign meddling in the US elections process.
Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance, a Democrat, is seeking Trump’s tax returns in a criminal investigation of the president, the Trump Organisation, and his family real estate business.
The cases will test how the justices view Trump’s arguments that the subpoenas are a threat to the presidency, on the one hand, and the need for lawmakers or prosecutors for information to pursue legislation or criminal investigations on the other.
The court has a 5-4 conservative majority including two Trump appointees, Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh.
The justices are scheduled at their private meeting today to discuss at least one case – Trump’s appeal of a lower court ruling allowing a New York grand jury to subpoena his accounting firm Mazars LLP for his records.
Trump’s attorneys said prosecutors could be encouraged to investigate a president to advance their careers or score political points if that subpoena is enforced.
Another case the justices could discuss is a lower court decision in Washington that endorsed subpoenas issued by the Democratic-led House Oversight Committee to Mazars.
Trump’s lawyers say there was no legislative purpose for the subpoenas and that the aim was to dig for dirt on him.
The justices could also act in a third case in which Trump is attempting to put on hold a lower court ruling allowing the enforcement of separate House committee subpoenas targeting Trump-related financial records from Deutsche Bank AG and Capital One Financial Corp.
The lower court rulings in the congressional cases, if left intact, would bring House Democrats closer to getting some of the details about Trump’s business interests even as they pursue impeaching him on his dealings with Ukraine.
That outcome would also amount to a major blow for the president, who, unlike past presidents, has refused to publicly disclose his tax returns.
Legal experts say the justices often hear cases when the president asks them to, but that does not mean Trump will ultimately prevail.
LEAVE A COMMENT Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*
With hospitals stressed, US enters ‘peak death week’
Brazil-China diplomatic spat over virus supplies escalates
With hospitals stressed, US enters 'peak death week' in coronavirus crisis
Qatar launches Coronavirus Information Service on WhatsApp
Acting US Navy chief says fired ship captain may have been 'stupid'
US deaths surpass 9,300 in ‘Pearl Harbour’ moment
Brazil lawmakers pass ‘war budget’ to fight virus crisis
New York state virus toll tops 4,000 with 594 new deaths in 24 hours
US enters 'hardest, saddest' week in coronavirus crisis