Judicial sources said the students are Finnegan Lee Elder, 19, and Gabriel Christian Natale-Hjorth, 18, both from San Francisco. They face charges of murder and attempted extortion.
The picture of Natale-Hjorth with head bowed and eyes covered by a blue blindfold at a police station started circulating on the Internet on Saturday and was published by several Italian newspapers on Sunday.
Police did not deny the authenticity of the picture.
"The general command of the (military police) Carabinieri disassociate themselves from the release and disclosure of photos of persons arrested for the murder of (officer) Mario Cerciello Rega," they said in a statement late on Saturday.
"The Carabinieri command in Rome is carrying out with extreme urgency an investigation to identify who is responsible."
Later on Sunday, one police source said the investigation had found an officer responsible, adding he would be immediately moved to a non-operational role.
There was no official confirmation of that.
Human rights associations condemned the picture as disturbing, but Italy's Interior Minister Matteo Salvini dismissed the controversy.
"To those who complain about the blindfolding of a person arrested, I remind them that the only victim to cry for is a ... Carabiniere ... who died while doing his job, killed by people who, if guilty, deserve spending their life in prison," Salvini said on Twitter.
LEAVE A COMMENT Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*
Poland’s populists eye election victory
Significant work to do, but Brexit deal still possible - UK PM Johnson
Brexit hangs in the balance as talks between EU and Britain intensify
Hundreds detained in climate protests
William and Kate embark on ‘complex’ Pakistan visit
Catalan separatist leaders to get up to 15 years in jail
Former head of scandal-hit Swedish Academy dies of cancer
'Super-human' Kipchoge busts mythical two-hour marathon barrier
UN chief urges end to ‘coal addiction’