Children’s rights advocates Save the Children Philippines (SCP) has urged the Senate to reject the efforts of Congress to lower the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility (MACR) from 15 years old to either nine or 12 years old.
Speaking before the Senate Committee on Justice and Human Rights chaired by Sen. Richard Gordon, SCP said lowering the MACR would result in the stigmatisation of children and would place undue burden on the country’s justice and social welfare system.
“We believe that lowering the MACR will result in criminalising more and younger children, which has a profound impact on their well-being and development, and place a massive demand on our justice and social welfare system that is already struggling to properly implement the existing Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act (of 2006),” SCP’s Wilma Banaga said.
Banaga said children who perceive themselves as criminals would likely to continue to engage in deviant behaviours particularly with their peers.
SCP also lamented that despite the passage of Republic Act (RA) 10630, the “Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act of 2006,” the needed facilities and programmes for children in conflict with the law remained inadequate.
Banaga cited data from the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council which showed that of the required 114, there were only 58 operational Bahay Pag-asa (House of Hope), of which only eight were accredited by the Department of Social Welfare and Development, with three being operated by non-government organisations.
Bahay Pag-asa is a 24-hour care institution for children with pending cases in court or children who were convicted by the court who are above 12 but below 15 years old and who committed serious crimes as enumerated in RA 10630 or have repeat offences.
Similarly, the Salinlahi Alliance for Children’s Concerns also opposed the MACR of children in conflict with the law (CICL).
In a position paper submitted to the Gordon panel, Salinlahi said that a number of studies had disproved the claims of the proponents of the amendment to lower down MACR that “children, as young as 9 to 12 years old can act with discernment, comprehending fully well the consequences of their actions.”
Earlier, Senate President Vicente Sotto 3rd underscored the need to pass a new law that would address the need to save children from committing crimes, as the prevailing juvenile justice law did not result in bringing down the number of crimes committed by minors, many of which were violent in nature.
Sotto has filed a bill seeking to lower the age of criminal liability from the current 15 to 13 years old. “The objective is not to incarcerate children, but to place them in Bahay Pag-asa facilities across the country where they would be rehabilitated and given a chance to enjoy normal lives,” Sotto said.
“Part of the bill is to upgrade these facilities which the current law failed to address,” he added.
In 2017, Senate Minority Leader Franklin Drilon filed a similar bill lowering the minimum age to 12 years old.
The proposals of Sotto and Drilon are higher than the House-approved proposal, which was nine years old. Psychologists, pro-child groups and social workers opposed this, saying a child’s brain has not yet fully developed at adolescence and that the problem is the law’s implementation.
Gordon said that his panel was likely to come out with a report and recommendations on the proposal to lower the MACR.
A boy (centre) attends a protest against the lowering of the minimum age of criminal responsibility in front of the Senate building in Manila.