The EU took a step towards closer defence ties yesterday, with 23 states signing a landmark pact aiming to boost co-operation after Brexit and as Russia flexes its muscles to the east.
The permanent structured co-operation on defence agreement (PESCO) seeks to improve EU co-ordination on defence and weapons systems development.
It is part of efforts led by Germany and France to reboot the EU after Britain’s shock decision to quit and follows the announcement in June of a €5.5bn ($6.4bn) European Defence Fund.
The EU’s diplomatic chief Federica Mogherini hailed the agreement as “a new page of European defence”, saying that countries had already proposed more than 50 projects.
Similar efforts to deepen military links have been frustrated for decades, partly by Britain’s fierce opposition to anything that might lead to a European army.
But Brexit and Russia’s annexation of Crimea in 2014 has once again brought the need for a strong European security stance back into focus.
The shift in US policy under President Donald Trump - who berated European partners on military spending at a Nato summit in May – has also led many to question whether Washington can be relied upon to protect Europe as it has in the past.
“It was important for us especially after the election of the American president that we can organise ourselves independently as Europeans,” German Defence Minister Ursula von der Leyen said.
“This is complementary to Nato, but we also see that nobody will solve the security problems that Europe has in its neighbourhood – we have to do it ourselves.”
The North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (Nato) will retain its primary role, but Mogherini said the EU could offer resources the alliance does not have, such as navigating security and development issues in Africa.
PESCO could, in theory, lead to the creation of a European operational headquarters or logistics base, but will first focus on projects to develop new military equipment such as tanks or drones.
The agreement commits countries to “regularly increasing defence budgets in real terms” as well as devoting 20% of defence spending to procurement and 2% on research and technology.
Mogherini said that by co-ordinating their efforts, European countries would get better value for money in defence.
“The real issue is not how much we spend but the fact we spend in a fragmented manner,” she said.
The deal also binds countries to provide “substantial support” in areas, including personnel, for EU military missions – an area that has proved problematic in the past.
Countries signing up to PESCO will be subject to an annual review to make sure they stick to their commitments – and could be thrown out if they do not.
After yesterday’s ceremony, the deal is set to be formally launched on the eve of the next EU summit in December, at which point it will become legally binding.
Paris and Berlin offered competing visions for the pact, with France pushing for a smaller group of nations to commit to ambitious projects including possible foreign interventions such as in Libya or Mali.
Germany wanted as many countries as possible to sign up but for it to undertake more modest schemes, and Berlin’s vision looks to have won the day.
Frederic Mauro, a defence expert who advises the European Parliament, said that he was “deeply sceptical” about the final form of the pact, describing it as “light years” away from the concept of defence co-operation foreseen in EU treaties.
“The Germans say respect unity and proceed modestly at the start with ... all these little projects – they won’t help the EU’s independent capacity,” Mauro told AFP. “It has no chance of working.”
New projects will require the unanimous approval of all countries that have signed up for PESCO, making it harder to get agreement on contentious issues.
Britain, which is leaving the EU, and Denmark, which has an opt-out in defence matters, did not sign, along with Ireland, Portugal and Malta.
British foreign minister Boris Johnson said that even though it was not taking part, the UK saw promise in PESCO and pledged to be “supportive”.
Member states who choose to sit out now can join later – subject to approval by the early adopters.
Countries that are not in the EU can also take part in specific missions – opening the way to possible participation by nuclear power Britain after it leaves the bloc in 2019 – though they will have no role in decision-making.
EU Foreign Policy Chief Federica Mogherini (centre) with some foreign and defence ministers from 23 EU member states after they signed the PESCO agreement on the sidelines of a foreign affairs council at the European Council in Brussels.
