Bloomberg/Dubai
Dubai Group progress in its quest to restructure $6bn of debt after two years of talks underscores why investor perceptions of the emirate’s credit risk are improving more than twice as much as regional peers.
The cost of insuring the emirate’s debt for five years tumbled 199 basis points, or 1.99 percentage points, this year to 246 on Thursday, according to data provider Credit Management Association (CMA). That compares with a 68 basis-point decline in average credit default swaps in the Middle East to 261, the data show. Dubai’s contracts dropped to 238 on Thursday.
Dubai Group, whose parent company is owned by the emirate’s ruler Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al-Maktoum, is close to an agreement with creditors including Emirates NBD and Noor Islamic Bank to restructure the debt, four bankers familiar with the matter said.
Law firm Linklaters, which represents the so-called co-ordinating committee of creditors, is drafting the accord and a final agreement may be reached as soon as mid-December, the people said, speaking on condition of anonymity because the talks are private.
“Dubai’s credit rally this year has been astonishing,” Gabriel Sterne, fixed-income economist at Exotix Holdings in London, said by phone. The rally has been paced by the emirate’s economic recovery and “worries fading about restructuring,” he said.
Over the past two years, several Dubai-based companies including property developer Nakheel restructured more than $40bn of liabilities accumulated before the global financial crisis.
Dubai Group used cheap loans to invest in financial services companies and property in the US. The company, which also owes another $4bn to shareholders, holds stakes in companies including Dubai-based investment bank Shuaa Capital and BankMuscat, Oman’s biggest bank by assets.
The worst global recession since the Great Depression led to a slump of more than 65% in the emirate’s property prices. Dubai’s economy shrank 2.4% in 2009 and its credit risk soared to as high as 942 on February 17, as concern swirled that the government wouldn’t back debts of state-linked companies. The swaps began receding after the central bank of the UAE, stepped in six days later with financial support.
Since then, the emirate has taken steps to address its debt crisis. Dubai World, one of its three main state-controlled holding companies, reached a deal in March 2011 with about 80 banks to delay payments on about $15bn of loans. This year Drydocks World, the Middle East’s biggest shipyard, restructured $2.2bn in August, developer Limitless restructured a $1.2bn Islamic loan in October and Dubai International Capital reached an accord to alter terms of $2.5bn of liabilities in April.
The emirate isn’t concerned about refinancing outstanding debt, Sheikh Ahmed bin Saeed al-Maktoum, the head of Dubai’s Supreme Fiscal Policy, said November 12. Dubai has “dealt quite effectively and proactively with the refinancing needs, but also there has been quite a lot of progress in the restructuring,” Masood Ahmed, head of the International Monetary Fund’s Middle East and Central Asia department, said in an interview this month.
Dubai’s economy may grow more than 4% next year, Sami al-Qamzi, director general of the city’s Department of Economic Development, said at the World Economic Forum this month. The yield on Dubai’s 5.591% dollar bonds tumbled 150 basis points this year to 4.48% on Thursday. It reached a record low of 4.39% on October 19, data show.
Dubai Group’s deal envisages interest of 1% to 2.5% and was proposed by the company earlier this year, the people said.
“Getting this debt restructuring out of the way would be positive for banks,” said Shabbir Malik, a Dubai-based analyst at investment bank EFG-Hermes Holding.
Dubai Group’s restructuring has led to loan losses at banks. Emirates NBD said in July it had set aside 32% of the value of Dubai Group’s loans, or 1.47bn dirhams ($400mn), to cover for losses as a result of the debt restructuring.
“Banks remain cautious because some investors with stakes in real estate are still facing challenges,” Malik said “The UAE’s real estate market has picked up but it is still selective. Once we see a broad-based recovery in the real estate market, then risk appetite should improve.”
The creditor group, comprised of about 35 banks, is seeking to win approval from Royal Bank of Scotland Group, Standard Bank Group and Commerzbank for the deal, three of the people said. The three banks walked away from the lender group in July because of a lack of progress.
“This is a positive development and a continuation of Dubai’s ability to restructure its liabilities,” said Tariq Qaqish, deputy head of asset management at Al Mal Capital. “Dubai’s economy is showing signs of improvement,” ha said.
Boats seen at moorings in the harbor area at the Dubai Marina development in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. The cost of insuring the emirate’s debt for