The Republican presidential race veered into vicious personal attacks Saturday as White House hopefuls brawled in their latest debate, with frontrunner Donald Trump and Jeb Bush locking horns in some of the campaign’s most pointed clashes to date.
The showdown, the ninth of the months-long battle for the Republican nomination, began with a respectful moment of silence for iconic conservative US supreme court justice Antonin Scalia who died suddenly earlier in the day.
But with a primary just one week away in South Carolina, a state where national politics often gets dragged into the mud, the debate in Greenville quickly turned nasty and divisive, with billionaire Trump, former Florida governor Bush, and senator Ted Cruz exchanging heated verbal blows.
“You are the single biggest liar,” Trump told Cruz when the Texas senator challenged him on his previous support for liberal policies.
Trump, visibly irritated, repeatedly interrupted his rivals, especially Bush, whose momentum he is seeking to blunt in a state where his dynastic family remains popular.
He went after Bush on foreign policy and immigration, and lambasted Jeb’s brother president George W Bush’s war in Iraq as “a big fat mistake”.
He even said Jeb’s mother should have been the 2016 Bush candidate instead of her son.
“Jeb is so wrong,” Trump sneered, to loud boos from the audience.
Bush parried back, hitting Trump’s suggestion he could work with Russia to combat the Islamic State jihadist group in Syria and Iraq, and saying the real estate magnate gets his foreign policy advice from “the shows”, referring to weekly Sunday morning talk shows.
“While Donald Trump was building a reality TV show, my brother was building a security apparatus to keep us safe. And I’m proud of what he did,” Bush fumed.
“The World Trade Center came down during your brother’s reign,” Trump shot back. “Remember that.”
It was an extraordinary back and forth on the national stage, with candidates often ignoring the moderators and going after each other in perhaps the most aggressive exchanges of the nine Republican debates to date.
“We’re in danger of driving this into the dirt,” one of the CBS debate moderators said at one point.
With the first two nomination contests in Iowa and New Hampshire under their collective belt, the candidates vying to be their party’s standardbearer are blanketing the so-called Palmetto State known for its bare-knuckle politics.
Cruz won Iowa, with Trump finishing an embarrassing second after proclaiming for weeks he would win. But The Donald bounced back to win New Hampshire, and holds a substantial lead in South Carolina.
The state holds its Republican primary February 20, the same day Democrats vote in Nevada for either Hillary Clinton or Bernie Sanders.
Trump, whose insurgent campaign has turned the presidential race on its head, on Friday made legal threats against his nearest rival Cruz, who was born in Canada, claiming the latter is not a “natural born citizen” and therefore unqualified to run for president.
But the most memorable clashes Saturday were between Trump and Bush, who has stepped up his aggressive campaigning and criticism of Trump.
John Kasich, who placed an impressive second in New Hampshire, has sought to keep his head above water in the more conservative, more evangelical South Carolina.
On the debate stage he steered clear of the daggers.
“I don’t want to get into all this fighting tonight because people are frankly sick of the negative campaigning,” he said.
Meanwhile, campaigns and their supporters have saturated South Carolina’s airwaves with negative advertising, including a harsh takedown of Trump by a pro-Bush group that criticized Trump for denigrating women, associating with the Clintons and for insulting decorated war heroes.
Despite the feuding, the Republican hopefuls came together as one to oppose president Barack Obama nominating a successor to Scalia on the Supreme Court.
Rubio, seeking a breakout moment after fizzling in New Hampshire, said Obama should not move to fill Scalia’s seat, noting lame duck presidents in their final year in office have not had a supreme court nominee confirmed for decades.
If he did, he would “ram down our throat a liberal justice, like the ones Barack Obama has imposed on us already”, he said.
Trump said he would impose taxes on Carrier air conditioning units manufactured in Mexico in light of the company’s decision to move production from Indiana, a position in line with his strong opposition to international trade deals.
Video of the company’s announcement last week to employees went viral on the Internet, showing emotional reactions to the loss of jobs while a representative of the company explained the move was “strictly a business decision.” Carrier, a manufacturer of air conditioning units, is owned by United Technologies Corp and announced it would be moving 1,400 jobs to Monterrey, Mexico.
“I’m going to tell them, ‘Now I’m going to get consensus from Congress and we’re going to tax you,’” Trump said. “’So stay where you are [in Mexico] or build in the United States.’ Because we are killing ourselves with trade pacts that are no good for us and no good for our workers.”
A central part of Trump’s campaign message has been his opposition to trade pacts that allow products manufactured overseas to be imported with limited or no tariffs. It’s a position that reverberates with middle- and low- income Americans, who have watched manufacturing jobs leave the country.
Trump cited the video of the workers, which has more than 2.8mn views on YouTube, at the debate.
“If you saw the people, because they have a video of the announcement that Carrier is moving to Mexico, they were laid off,” he said. “They were crying. It was a very sad situation.”