No alternative for Europe

By now, it is obvious that Donald Trump’s return to the US presidency has inaugurated a process of historical reordering. One of the first and largest casualties of Trump’s policy initiatives is the transatlantic relationship, which has anchored the global order since it emerged from the Allied victory over Nazi Germany in 1945 (and which had been reinforced by the West’s victory in the Cold War after 1989).Thus, the current reordering (undertaken with little or no preparation) will come largely at the expense of the Old Continent. Even as Europeans face the return of war to their borders with the ongoing fighting in Ukraine, the new US administration apparently longs for the return of the American troops now stationed in Europe to the Americas. What will become of us? This is a question that we Europeans must answer wholly on our own.Make no mistake: the United States is withdrawing from Europe. A full departure may not yet have been decided, but all signs point to this outcome, and Europeans therefore should act as if it will happen.Moreover, the US is not only pulling away; it is also giving up its roles as a guarantor power and the leading market within a global free-trade system. Already, its unilateral economic aggression toward friends and trading partners has thrown the global economic order off balance. Protectionism has replaced free trade, and the losses are mounting. The world is heading toward tariff-based trade blocs that will mirror the new geopolitical blocs of the twenty-first century.Since the end of World War II, Western Europe has sheltered beneath America’s security umbrella. These countries shared values favoring democracy and a market economy – values that were embraced by almost the entirety of Europe after the Cold War. But America’s looming withdrawal creates a radically different situation for Europeans.Europeans must prepare for a future in which they are squeezed between an imperial, aggressive Russia and an America that can no longer be trusted. That means answering the fundamental question that this historical turning point has raised: Are we willing to do what it takes to transform ourselves into a viable power in our own right?If the people of Europe answer in the affirmative, the mechanics of European sovereignty – the military, political, fiscal, economic, technological, and scientific underpinnings – must take centre stage. To be sovereign means to trust in one’s own strength and political will.We are experiencing not only a geopolitical upheaval, but also a seismic technological and economic shift. The digital revolution and the rise of AI will have far-reaching consequences for all economies and societies, as well as for the multifaced relationships among them.In the face of these disruptions, traditional European nation-states will be able to keep pace and prosper only if they come together to express a shared political will. Each on its own – even the largest (Germany) – is too small for the task.The external pressures Europe faces are difficult to overstate. Russian President Vladimir Putin continues to wage war on Ukraine and threaten the rest of Eastern Europe. The Trump administration has shown nothing but contempt for us, and is apparently committed to inflicting more economic pain on America and its trade partners. Meanwhile, China is steaming ahead in its own pursuit of AI and advanced military hardware.All these pressures will continue to grow in the months and years ahead. But Europeans still have agency. We can frame our plight as an opportunity to build anew. The challenge is not only to overcome entrenched sources of internal and external resistance, but also to preserve our diverse identities.This chance must not be wasted. Trump and Putin may not be the ideal ones to have been picked for this moment, but they are what Europeans have. Europe must assert itself as a sovereign power and move forward on its own. There is no alternative unless Europeans opt for a future of craven subservience.There is a need to establish military deterrence, create the dynamic conditions needed for domestic digitalisation and innovation, establish a single capital market, and muster some form of shared political will and the institutions to realise it in practice, based on common democratic values. In short, Europe must unite as a free, sovereign power. Failing that, the continent will be at the mercy of external actors who would like nothing more than to see Europe come apart and decline into a state of perpetual weakness and subjugation.