International

Post-Thackeray: will the debts disappear with the creditor?

Post-Thackeray: will the debts disappear with the creditor?

November 27, 2012 | 08:46 PM

Mumbai’s uncrowned king Bal Thackeray is no more. For decades, his writ ran unchallenged throughout the nation’s financial capital. As the Shiv Sena supremo, he held indisputable sway over the minds of Mumbaikars and could bring Mumbai and the entire Maharashtra to a standstill when he was alive. He could do it even with his death, despite the contradiction of how a man who never held a public office and whose politics was founded on fear could have wooed such crowds to his last journey. The government, as usual, was only too willing to kowtow and offer him a public cremation with full state honours that too at Shivaji Park in Dadar although he never fought an election, much less held a formal position in government. Was it in recognition of his politics of hate and ideology of exclusion and division, implemented through violence or his political prowess that evoked unquestioned adulation among his followers and fear among those who did not fall in line with his views? The question begs an answer.What is unfortunate, however, is that while Thackeray swore allegiance to the Marathi people, his contribution to their economic and social progress - even when his party headed the government - was, at best, derisory. The ‘sons of the soil’ were not offered land or employment, but were taught who to blame and target for all their miseries: the south Indians, Gujaratis, Uttar Praseshis, Biharis and Muslims. The misguided campaigns left a trail of death, destruction and bitterness in their wake even as they snuffed out the cosmopolitan ethos of Mumbai. As a strategy of political mobilisation, this worked wonderfully well. Like Hitler, whom he admired, Thackeray knew how to command loyalty and inflame passions. Every failing of his opponents and official slackness in checking the use of organised violence as principal political tool added to his muscle power.Mumbai’s communal fault lines were thoroughly exploited by Thackeray and his cohorts, especially in the weeks after the demolition of the Babri Masjid in December 1992. As the Srikrishna Commission documented, Muslims were systematically killed in riots engineered by Sena leaders. The power to wreak havoc implies the power to offer patronage. Many from different worlds of politics, business and films took that patronage. The result has been a politics of fear and loathing, that has little in common with democracy, of glittering achievement built not so much on solid striving and merit as on pre-empted competition. When the Shiv Sena first burst out of the lanes of what was then a heavily industrialised city named Mumbai, it was used as a stick by the Congress leadership of Maharashtra to beat Left-leaning trade unions into submission. The violence and disruption of those years, the murders of political opponents and the anti-outsider riots played a large part in the de-industrialisation of what was once India’s greatest manufacturing centre. The final years of Thackeray saw the tiger fighting extinction. The Hindutva wave that swept the Shiv Sena to power in 1995 has slowly ebbed. The Shiv Sena has not won Maharashtra since 1999, despite an ineffective ruling government. Its iron party discipline has rusted, its cadre was plagued by defections. When Narayan Rane left for the Congress in 2005, he took with him the Shiv Sena’s only hope of winning the Konkan coast. Thackeray’s insistence on hoisting his son as successor led to his charismatic nephew Raj Thackeray forming his own party Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) and splitting the Sena vote-bank. An ageing Thackeray responded to these challenges, not with the machinations of a swift-footed politician with a vision, but with the doggedness of a believer. He railed against Bangladeshis polluting his beloved city, and refused Pakistan permission to play cricket in India. He continued demonising migrants and minorities. Public violence remained his conscious, strident strategy. Death of a leader in any strictly personality-driven party, inevitably, triggers a full-fledged power struggle among the ambitious heirs. The post-Thackeray twists too are worth watching. Some debts do disappear with the creditor. The question in everyone’s mind is: will the Shiv Sena reinvent itself into a kinder, gentler party or will it continue with its bizarre concept of constructive violence? For the moment what certainly did not die away is Thackeray’s legacy: the politics of violent intimidation, crushing dissent and individual rights, aided and abetted, of course, by a state machinery that caves in before such mob rule.Two young women have been arrested for questioning why the city had shut down to mark the death of a politician. A clinic belonging to an uncle of one of the women has been ransacked in subsequent vandalism by Sainiks. There is a larger dimension to the arrests of 21-year-old Shaheen Dhada and Renu, the former for posting her comment on Facebook and the latter for “liking” it. Increasingly, individual rights are being trampled upon by the state to pander to fringe groups with a potential for violence or mischief. The Shiv Sena is not the only such fringe group, and Maharashtra is not the only state where this happens as residents of West Bengal know very well. What stands out in this episode, and similar ones earlier, is the alacrity with which the police made arbitrary arrests and cloaked their censorial actions using a combination of Indian Penal Code sections that have no place in a free country, and the infamous Section 66A of the Information Technology Act which deals with offensive messages. After all, what can be so illegal about expressing an innocuous opinion about so public an event as the complete shutdown of the country’s financial capital? The arrest of these women, who must be still wondering what they had done that was so wrong, has drawn widespread condemnation. The expression of distress by Telecom and IT Minister Kapil Sibal and his articulated intention to amend the relevant IT Act further reaffirms this position. As a nation, India must worry about the rapidly shrinking space for freedom of speech and expression, and act resolutely now. Section 66A of the IT Act which nullifies constitutional free speech guarantees must go. Equally, the leadership that rules with the people’s mandate must quell the proclivity for violence towards people with a counter view.

November 27, 2012 | 08:46 PM