Opinion

India’s skewed strategy to blame for Mumbai defeat

India’s skewed strategy to blame for Mumbai defeat

November 27, 2012 | 12:32 AM

England’s thrashing of India by 10 wickets in the Mumbai Test yesterday should lead to a serious change in the way the Indian cricket establishment conducts its business.

While England deserve all credit for a rare win on Indian soil by strangling their rivals with spin, the fact cannot be denied that the hosts paid a heavy price for refusing to learn from the mistakes of the past.

M S Dhoni’s insistence on a wicket that “turned from the first day” boomeranged on the team as they capitulated against Monty Panesar, a left-arm spinner, who started his career with a great deal of promise only to lose his way somewhat. His 11 wickets in the Mumbai Test, however, have offered him a lifeline besides handing England the momentum in the two remaining Tests at Kolkata and Nagpur.

India have been good players of spin bowling but it’s a modern-day myth that they are absolutely invincible against the turning ball. Panesar and Graeme Swann proved that much beyond doubt with their heroics in Mumbai.

 The formula of producing dustbowls that passes for cricket pitches and throwing the ball to spinners to complete the formalities has worked wonders for India in the past.  Ajit Wadekar pioneered that concept when he was the coach of the Indian team for a considerable number of years in the 90s.

That strategy started producing mixed results after Wadekar departed and foreign coaches like John Wright, Greg Chappell and Gary Kirsten coming in. Australia in fact conquered the “Final Frontier” in 2004 and other teams like South Africa and Pakistan have also held their own while visiting India.

However, India are going through a crisis that began almost after their World Cup success in April 2011 The tours of England and Australia proved disastrous with India losing all the eight Tests unable to cope with conditions suited to fast bowlers. And Dhoni’s desperate bid to get a measure of revenge over England by ordering rank turners appears destined to fail for a variety of reasons.

To start with players like Rahul Dravid, Sourav Ganguly  and VVS Laxman, excellent players against spin, have quit Test cricket. Sachin Tendulkar, whose exploits against the best spinner of all time, Shane Warne, are part of cricketing folklore, is a shadow of himself. The way he got out to Panesar in both innings is further proof that his once undisputed powers are on the wane.

Harbhajan Singh, who was also a handful on Indian pitches in the past, appeared clueless on the Mumbai wicket tailor made for spinners like him. Only left-arm spinner Pragyan Ojha acquitted himself well and in retrospect it can be said that India should have played a leg-spinner instead of two off-spinners in Harbhajan and R  Ashwin.

The Mumbai result has thrown the Indian team’s strategy into confusion. What sort of wickets Dhoni would demand of the curators in Kolkata and Nagpur? A wicket that is of no use to the spinners or fast bowlers perhaps. We have seen plenty of that too in the past.

November 27, 2012 | 12:32 AM